Salt Lake City · Car Accident Guide
In Utah, a broken bone or $3,000 in medical bills is the line that decides whether you can claim pain and suffering from the driver who hit you, and many crash victims never learn the fracture rule exists. We compared three car accident attorneys serving Salt Lake City on license records, the case types they actually list, what they publish about fees, and a read of recent Google reviews, and set out who each one suits and where each falls short.
DJA Editorial · Legal Directory Research
Checked against state bar licensee records, court sources and public review platforms · Last updated October 2026
The short answer
Three firms serving Salt Lake City drivers, each leading for a different situation. This is a shortlist rather than a ranking. Two of the three practice from Midvale rather than downtown, and none of them publishes its fee percentage.
1
Waddoups Law Personal Injury Attorneys
Best for a family firm with a written net recovery guarantee
2
Robert J. DeBry & Associates
Best for an injured client who needs the firm to come to them
3
Strong Law Accident & Injury Attorneys
Best for a crash involving an out-of-state driver or insurer
At a glance: Car Accident Attorneys in Salt Lake City, compared
| Firm |
Best for |
Focus |
Bar record |
Fees |
Rating |
| Waddoups Law Personal Injury Attorneys |
Best for a family firm with a written net recovery guarantee |
Car, truck and wrongful death claims |
George T. Waddoups, in practice since 1982 |
Contingency, net recovery guarantee |
5.0 · 110 Google |
| Robert J. DeBry & Associates |
Best for an injured client who needs the firm to come to them |
Car, truck and wrongful death claims |
Mike Banks, JD 2006 |
Contingency, free 24/7 consultation |
4.8 · 722 Google |
| Strong Law Accident & Injury Attorneys |
Best for a crash involving an out-of-state driver or insurer |
Multi-state car and truck injury claims |
Jed Strong, licensed in Utah for about 13 years |
Contingency, rate explained before signing |
4.8 · 178 Google |
Car Accident in Salt Lake City: the local picture
$3,000
The line before you can sue for pain and suffering
Utah is a no-fault state. Your own PIP, which must be at least $3,000, pays first. You can claim pain and suffering from the at-fault driver only once medical expenses pass $3,000, or the crash caused a bone fracture, dismemberment, permanent disability or impairment, permanent disfigurement, or death. A single broken bone clears the line on its own.
0 of 3
Firms here that publish a fee percentage
All three work on contingency and none states its percentage online. Utah’s professional conduct rules require a contingency agreement to be in writing and to say how the fee is calculated. Ask for the pre-suit and post-filing rates, and whether the fee is taken from the gross settlement or after case costs come out.
$20,000
Where you may not need a lawyer at all
Utah small claims hears money claims up to $20,000 through 2029, with simplified rules and no attorney required. A district court complaint for $10,000 or more costs $375 to file, and a judge can waive that fee for a filer whose income sits at or below 150% of the federal poverty guidelines, using a Motion to Waive Fees.
What clients in Salt Lake City say: Across a sample of recent Google reviews for all three, clients thank a named pair more often than a firm: George and Geri at Waddoups, Bryce Kartchner and paralegal Pam Logan or Peter Mifflin and Ana Campos at DeBry, and case staff such as LeighAnn and Emily at Strong Law. The praise is about being kept informed and having medical bills and insurers handled. The one pointed complaint we read concerned how a fee was calculated, not how a case was run. Ask who your pair will be, and how the fee is worked out.
How we chose these Car Accident Attorneys in Salt Lake City
We looked at three firms handling car accident claims for Salt Lake City drivers and compared them on things a reader can check: the license history of the named attorneys, the case types each firm actually lists, what each publishes about fees and costs, where its Salt Lake County office is, and the text of recent client reviews on Google rather than the star average alone.
This is a shortlist, not a ranking, and each firm leads for a different situation. Firm details come from each firm’s own site, cross-checked against Google Business Profile listings, attorney directories, and news records, and the legal figures come from the Utah Code and Utah Courts pages. Utah State Bar numbers and discipline records we could not confirm during this update are flagged on the page rather than filled in, and every verdict, recovery total or success rate shown is labelled as the firm’s own figure.
1. Waddoups Law Personal Injury Attorneys
Best for a family firm with a written net recovery guarantee
★★★★★ 5.0 / 5 · Google · 110 reviews
A three-attorney family practice in Midvale run by George T. Waddoups, in practice since 1982, with his son Riley and Michelle Waddoups. What sets it apart on paper is a guarantee printed on its homepage: the client’s net recovery will not be less than the attorney fee. None of the other firms here puts a floor like that in writing. If you want an experienced auto accident lawyer in St. Louis, Missouri, who will also deal with your health insurer, clinics, and repair shop, that is what its reviewers describe, by name.
Identity and footprint
Office623 East Fort Union Blvd, Suite 108, Midvale, UT 84047
Location noteMidvale, in south Salt Lake County, not downtown Salt Lake City. There is no separate Salt Lake City office.
Phone801-212-9992, with a second number, 385-289-3947, shown mid-page
Registered nameAlso listed as George T. Waddoups & Associates
TeamGeorge T. Waddoups (founder and president), Riley T. Waddoups (partner), Michelle K. Waddoups, and Geri C. Kelley
Service areaStatewide, with city pages from Logan to St. George
Practice and scope
Core workInjury claims only
Car crash pagesDistracted, drowsy and drunk driving, head-on, hit and run, multi-vehicle, rear-end, rollover, T-bone, texting, dangerous roads, plus uninsured and underinsured motorist claims
Truck depthFifteen truck sub-pages, from underride and jackknife crashes to Amazon and garbage trucks
Firm’s stated track recordOver 1,200 mediations or arbitrations and, for George Waddoups, over 85 jury trials. These are the firm’s own figures and cannot be checked independently.
Published resultsFirm’s own figures include a $58.5 million 2013 wrongful death jury verdict involving a semi-truck, a $1.5 million DUI rear-end settlement, and $400,000 and $300,000 policy-limits auto settlements. The same $58.5 million figure also appears on another listed firm’s attorney bio as a trial team result, so ask each firm what its attorney’s role was.
Credentials and licensing
George T. WaddoupsJD, University of Memphis (Memphis State), in law since 1982 per his bio. Utah State Bar number and admission year:
Riley T. WaddoupsBA University of Utah 2003, JD Oklahoma City University School of Law. An attorney since 2008 per a directory profile, which still places him at Robert J. DeBry & Associates; the Waddoups site says he spent many years at one of Utah’s largest injury firms.
Michelle K. WaddoupsGraduated Thomas M. Cooley Law School 2010, admitted 2012 (Justia)
RecognitionGeorge Waddoups holds a Super Lawyers profile, linked from the firm site
Directory listingGeorge T. Waddoups holds a Distinguished Justice Advocates listing
Fees and consultation
StructureContingency, advertised as no win, no fee
GuaranteeThe firm guarantees the client’s net amount will not be less than the attorney fee
Costs if you loseThe firm states that if it does not recover, you owe nothing and it covers all costs
ConsultationFree
What clients say
✓ Riley named in most recent reviews
✓ Handles insurers, clinics and repairs
✓ Paralegal quick to answer
· No critical review in the sample read
· 110 reviews, all-5-star average
The most recent reviews mostly name Riley Waddoups, describing clear explanations and a paralegal who replies quickly. Older reviews on the firm’s own site name George and Geri, and one cyclist with a broken back and brain injury credits them with taking over dealings with doctors and insurers. We read no critical review, but a perfect average on 110 reviews says little about how disputes are handled.
Why they fit Salt Lake City: A good fit for a mid-sized claim where the real headache is coordination: health insurance, PIP, repair shop, providers and liens. The written net recovery guarantee is a concrete protection the other firms do not offer. Go in knowing three things: the office is in Midvale, this is a small team with limited room for several trials at once, and the headline verdict and trial counts are the firm’s own figures. Ask which Waddoups attorney will run your file and who would try it.
2. Robert J. DeBry & Associates
Best for an injured client who needs the firm to come to them
★★★★½ 4.8 / 5 · Google · 722 reviews
The longest-running name on this list and the only one with a downtown Salt Lake City office, on West Broadway. The firm says that if your injuries keep you at home or in hospital, its team will come to you, and its 722 Google reviews are the deepest record here. Founder Robert J. DeBry died in 2021, and the firm is now led by president Mike Banks. For a Utah car accident lawyer with a long Salt Lake presence and a Spanish-language site, this is the established option.
Identity and footprint
Salt Lake office35 W Broadway, Suite 300, Salt Lake City, UT 84101
Other officeSandy, per the firm site
Phone801-888-8888, answered 24 hours
LeadershipMike Banks, president. Partners Darren Davis and Sam Adams; attorneys Peter Mifflin, Ricky Shelton, Christian Cueva, Travis Alkire and Bryce Kartchner
FounderRobert J. DeBry, who died in May 2021 aged 85
Founding yearThe firm says 1981; the founder’s published obituary says 1980
LanguagesEnglish, with a Spanish language version of the site
Practice and scope
Core workInjury claims only, with car accidents described as the firm’s largest practice
Case pagesCar, truck, motorcycle, pedestrian, drunk driving, dog bite, slip and fall, wrongful death
Car crash guidesSeparate pages on the no-fault system, whiplash and delayed symptoms, total loss valuation, rental car crashes, and a Salt Lake City car accident page
Settlement rateThe firm states over 90% of cases settle without a lawsuit. This is the firm’s own figure.
Firm’s stated totalsOver $747 million recovered and about 10,000 Utahns helped. These are the firm’s own figures and cannot be checked independently.
Credentials and licensing
Mike BanksBA University of Utah 2003, JD Willamette University College of Law 2006, joined the firm after law school. His bio also says he joined Adams Davis, P.C. in 2015, so ask how the two firms relate.
LicensedFirm attorneys are licensed in Utah, Idaho and Wyoming
Founder’s recordRobert J. DeBry received a Lifetime Achievement Award from the Utah Association for Justice in 2011 Ratings shownFirm displays Martindale-Hubbell AV Preeminent, Super Lawyers and BBB A+ badges
Published resultMike Banks’s bio lists a $58.5 million wrongful death verdict as a trial team result. This is the firm’s own figure.
Fees and consultation
StructureContingency, advertised as no fee unless we win
ConsultationFree, available 24/7, with home or hospital visits for clients who cannot travel
What clients say
✓ Attorney and paralegal pairs named
✓ Kept informed throughout
✓ Handled a spinal cord injury case
✓ One account of a reduced fee
· Rating covers the downtown listing
Reviewers repeatedly name the same pairs, Bryce Kartchner with paralegal Pam Logan and Peter Mifflin with Ana Campos, and describe regular updates. One client with a complete spinal cord injury from a paragliding crash describes a two and a half year case with that team. A reviewer on the firm’s own site says the attorney cut his fee so the family kept more of the settlement; that is one account, not a policy.
Why they fit Salt Lake City: The strongest choice here if you cannot easily travel, want a downtown Salt Lake City office, or simply want the deepest verified review record. The trade off is that the name on the door no longer tells you who handles your case: the founder died in 2021, eight attorneys share the work, and the president’s own bio gives a confusing account of where he has practised. Ask which attorney and paralegal pair you will get, and get that in writing.
3. Strong Law Accident & Injury Attorneys
Best for a crash involving an out-of-state driver or insurer
★★★★½ 4.8 / 5 · Google · 178 reviews
A multi-state firm founded in 2016 by Jed Strong, who began on the other side as defense counsel for GEICO. Its Utah office is in Midvale, a few blocks along Fort Union Blvd from Waddoups, and Strong holds licences in Utah and at least eight other western states. That matters if the other driver, their insurer or you are based outside Utah. It is also the only firm here whose Salt Lake City car accident lawyer page explains the one-year notice rule for crashes involving a government vehicle.
Identity and footprint
Utah office193 East Fort Union Blvd, Midvale, UT 84047
Phone385-483-4682 on Google; the site header lists 206-741-1053, a Washington number
FounderJed Strong, CEO
Other officesTacoma and Everett WA, Eugene OR, Boise ID, Denver CO, Albuquerque NM, Anchorage AK
HoursThe firm’s FAQ says weekdays 9 to 5 with after-hours call backs, while its Google listing shows open 24 hours
Attorneys listedJed Strong, Ben Espana, Jozee Puglisi, Brian Wardlow, Tim Luetkemeyer, Tyler Eaton, Aryeh Carter, Caleb Miller
Practice and scope
Core workInjury claims only
Salt Lake City pagesCar, truck, pedestrian, bicycle, motorcycle, brain injury, catastrophic injury, wrongful death
Local dataPublishes its own five-year Salt Lake County fatal crash analysis, reporting 305 of 366 fatal crashes off the interstate system. This is the firm’s own analysis.
Government vehicle crashesIts car accident page flags the one-year notice of claim rule for crashes involving a public vehicle or road
Firm’s stated recordA 98% win rate in court and over 2,000 successful cases. These are the firm’s own figures and cannot be checked independently.
Credentials and licensing
Jed StrongJD, University of Hawaii Richardson School of Law. Licensed in Utah about 13 years, plus Washington, Oregon, Idaho, Colorado, Alaska, Arkansas, Montana, Oklahoma and Wyoming per a directory profile.
BackgroundDefense attorney for GEICO before founding the firm in 2016; earlier at Lowe Law Group
RecognitionTim Luetkemeyer is listed by The National Trial Lawyers, per the firm site
Fees and consultation
StructureContingency, no attorney fees unless compensation is recovered
PercentageNot published; the firm says the exact rate is explained before you hire it
ConsultationFree, described as never charged
Fee baseOne reviewer says the fee was taken from the full settlement, including money they had paid out of pocket. That is one account; ask how the fee is calculated before signing.
What clients say
✓ Clients who switched from another firm
✓ Staff named for fast answers
✓ Quick settlements described
✗ One complaint about fee base
· 178 reviews on the Midvale listing
Reviewers on the Midvale listing describe fast replies and name staff, including attorney Jozee Puglisi, LeighAnn and Emily. One client moved to Strong Law from a previous attorney in 2025 and says the paperwork finally got done. Against that, one reviewer warns the percentage was taken from the full settlement, including their own out-of-pocket payments. That is one account, but the question is worth asking any firm.
Why they fit Salt Lake City: The clearest fit when the claim crosses a state line: an out-of-state driver, a commercial carrier insured elsewhere, or a client who lives in Idaho, Colorado or Washington. The GEICO defense background is relevant to how your file will be valued. The trade off is that Utah is one office of a regional firm headquartered in Tacoma, the site’s phone number is a Washington line, and hours differ between the site and Google. Ask which Utah-licensed attorney will handle your case.
What to check before hiring a Car Accident Attorney in Salt Lake City
✓ Check the licence yourself
The Utah State Bar runs a free licensee search showing bar number, admission date, status and any public discipline. Search the attorney who will handle your file, not the firm name. None of the three firms here publishes bar numbers, and two of them list several attorneys, so the name matters.
✓ Find out if a broken bone puts you over the line
You do not need $3,000 in medical bills to claim pain and suffering if the crash caused a bone fracture, permanent impairment, permanent disfigurement or dismemberment. Ask the attorney at the first call which route you qualify under, because it decides whether your claim stays inside PIP.
✓ Get the percentage and the fee base in writing
Ask for the pre-suit rate, the rate after a lawsuit is filed, and whether it rises again at trial. Then ask whether the fee is calculated on the gross settlement or after costs and anything you paid yourself. A reviewer in this guide learned the answer after the fact.
✓ Ask who advances costs and what happens if you lose
Records, filing fees and outside reports are usually advanced by the firm and repaid from the settlement. One firm here says it absorbs costs if there is no recovery; the others do not publish their policy. Get the answer before you sign.
✓ Flag a government vehicle on day one
If the crash involved a UTA bus, a city or county vehicle, a public employee or a public road defect, a written notice of claim is generally due within one year, far shorter than the usual four years. Raise it at the first call.
✓ Ask who your contact person will be
At all three firms, reviewers thank a paralegal or case manager as often as the attorney. That is normal. Ask for both names, how often you will hear from them, and when the attorney gets personally involved.
Car Accident Attorneys in Salt Lake City: frequently asked questions
How much does a car accident attorney cost in Salt Lake City?
Nothing upfront at any of the three firms here; all work on contingency. None publishes its percentage, so ask for the pre-suit and post-filing rates and whether the fee is taken from the gross settlement. Utah’s conduct rules require the agreement to be in writing and to state how the fee is calculated.
Utah is a no-fault state, so can I still sue the other driver?
Yes, once you clear the threshold. Your own PIP, at least $3,000, pays first. You can then claim pain and suffering from the at-fault driver if your medical expenses exceed $3,000, or if the crash caused a bone fracture, dismemberment, permanent disability or impairment, permanent disfigurement, or death. The threshold does not apply to an uninsured motorist claim.
How long do I have to file a car accident claim in Utah?
Generally four years from the crash for an injury lawsuit. Wrongful death claims have two years. If a government vehicle, employee or road is involved, a notice of claim is generally due within one year, so confirm your deadline early rather than counting on the four.
What if I was partly at fault for the crash?
Utah uses modified comparative fault. Your recovery is reduced by your share of fault, and if you are 50% or more at fault you recover nothing. Insurers often argue for a percentage rather than total fault, because even 20% cuts what they pay.
What if the other driver only had the minimum insurance?
Utah’s minimum liability limits are $30,000 per person, $65,000 per crash and $25,000 for property damage. A serious injury can use that up quickly, which is where uninsured and underinsured motorist coverage on your own policy matters. Check your declarations page.
Is my claim too small to need a lawyer?
Possibly. Utah small claims hears disputes up to $20,000 through 2029 with no attorney required. On a clear fault claim with modest bills, a contingency fee can cost more than a lawyer adds. Filing in district court costs $375 for claims of $10,000 or more, and the fee can be waived for filers who qualify on income.
DJA Editorial
Legal Directory Research
Compiles Distinguished Justice Advocates city guides from state bar and directory records, court and statute sources, and publicly visible client reviews. Firms appear as a shortlist rather than a ranking. Figures a firm publishes about itself are labelled as such, and anything that could not be verified is flagged on the page rather than estimated.