Peekskill · Criminal Defense Guide
An arrest in Peekskill starts on the second floor of 2 Nelson Avenue, in the same building as the Peekskill Police Department, where City Court hears misdemeanors and arraigns felonies before they move to White Plains. We compared three criminal defense lawyers in Peekskill using New York attorney registration records, the cases each actually focuses on, their fee statements, and the Google reviews we could read.
DJA Editorial · Legal Directory Research
Checked against state bar licensee records, court sources, and public review platforms
The short answer
Three Peekskill practices within a few blocks of each other and of City Court, each suited to a different kind of case. This is a shortlist, not a ranking.
1
Levine & Montana
Best for a charge where a former prosecutor’s read of the case matters
2
Law Office of Robert M. Nachamie
Best for DWI and traffic charges in Westchester and Dutchess courts
3
John M. Voelp Esq. PLLC
Best for a criminal charge tied to other legal problems, from a long-serving local generalist
At a glance: Criminal Defense Lawyers in Peekskill, compared
| Firm |
Best for |
Focus |
Bar record |
Fees |
Rating |
| Levine & Montana |
Best for a charge where a former prosecutor’s read of the case matters |
Misdemeanors, felonies, DWI, plus real estate |
Matthew Montana, New York 2009 |
Free consultation, fixed fees listed in directories |
5.0 · 103 Google |
| Law Office of Robert M. Nachamie |
Best for DWI and traffic charges in Westchester and Dutchess courts |
Criminal, DWI and traffic |
Robert Nachamie, New York 2002 |
Payment plans, credit cards accepted |
4.7 · 12 Google |
| John M. Voelp Esq. PLLC |
Best for a criminal charge tied to other legal problems, from a long-serving local generalist |
General practice including criminal and DUI |
John Voelp, New York 1976, #1092097 |
Not published |
4.3 · 6 reviews |
Criminal Defense in Peekskill: the local picture
$200 to $375
Fees the court adds to any conviction
On top of any fine, New York adds a mandatory surcharge and crime victim fee: $200 for a misdemeanor and $325 for a felony, plus a $50 DNA fee for felonies and Penal Law misdemeanors. The judge cannot waive them. None of the three firms below publishes its own legal fees.
90 days
How long the prosecution has to be ready
For a class A misdemeanor, the District Attorney generally must be ready for trial within 90 days of the case starting, and within six months for a felony, not counting delays the defense causes or agrees to. Peekskill City Court handles misdemeanors; felonies move to Westchester County Court after indictment.
250%
The income line for a free lawyer
If your take-home pay is at or below 250% of the federal poverty guidelines, you are presumed eligible for assigned counsel at no cost, appointed at your first court appearance. In Westchester, the Legal Aid Society handles felonies, and the assigned counsel panel handles misdemeanors and violations. Call 914-286-3400.
What clients in Peekskill say: Across the reviews we could read, Peekskill clients praise the same thing at all three offices: a lawyer who picks up the phone and explains where the case stands. Outcomes come up often, such as a dismissal, a DWI reduced to a lesser charge, or a ticket with no points, but those are individual accounts, not a record of results. The complaints focus on manners and time: one long wait for a scheduled appointment and one rude text message. Two of the three firms have fewer than fifteen Google reviews.
How we chose these Criminal Defense Lawyers in Peekskill
We looked at practices handling criminal cases in Peekskill City Court and the Westchester courts, then compared them on things you can check yourself: the New York attorney registration record for the named attorney, the criminal and DWI work each firm actually lists, what they say about fees and consultations, where the office is, and the client reviews visible on Google.
The three are a shortlist, not a ranking, and each fits a different situation. We pull firm details from each firm’s site, cross-check them against Google Business Profile listings, New York Office of Court Administration registration data, Martindale, Lawyers.com, Justia, and New York court and statute sources. Anything we could not confirm against the official attorney search is flagged on the page. No case result appears here as a fact; review accounts are labeled as one client’s account.
1. Levine & Montana
Best for a charge where a former prosecutor’s read of the case matters
★★★★★ 5.0 / 5 · Google · 103 reviews
Matthew Montana runs the criminal side of Levine & Montana, a two-lawyer firm, and, according to his directory profile, spent six and a half years as an Assistant District Attorney in Manhattan before joining the practice his family has run in Peekskill since 1980. That background helps you judge what a Westchester prosecutor will actually offer. With 103 Google reviews, the largest base here, and Spanish spoken, he is the professional criminal defense lawyer in Peekskill most reviewers name personally.
Identity and footprint
Office1200 Brown Street, Suite 200, Peekskill, NY 10566
Address noteThe firm’s own site still lists 1019 Park Street, PO Box 668. Confirm which door to go to before your visit.
Phone(914) 737-3515
HoursMonday to Thursday 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., Friday 9 a.m. to 1 p.m.
AttorneysMatthew P. Montana (criminal) and Lewis C. Montana (managing partner, real estate)
LanguagesEnglish and Spanish
Practice and scope
Criminal workViolations, misdemeanors, and felonies
Other workResidential and commercial real estate, co-op and condo, landlord and tenant, wills and estates
Firm siteA single page naming real estate and criminal defense as the two areas, established in 1980
Federal courtsMatthew Montana is listed as admitted in the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York
Charges in reviewsDWI, cases reported as dismissed, and general criminal matters. These are client accounts, not a published record.
Credentials and licensing
New York bar admissionMatthew Peter Montana, admitted 2009, currently registered
Law schoolNew England School of Law
Prosecutor backgroundSix and a half years as an Assistant District Attorney in the Manhattan DA’s Office, per his directory profile
Managing partnerLewis Charles Montana, admitted 1977, Georgetown University Law Center, registration 1065556
Fees and consultation
ConsultationFree initial consultation
StructureDirectories list fixed hourly rates and fixed fees as available
What clients say
✓ Matt Montana named personally
✓ Clear, quick communication
✓ Spanish-speaking clients served
· Largest review base here
Almost all reviews we read name Matthew Montana rather than the firm. Clients describe a lawyer who returned calls, explained each step, and kept them informed; several also describe outcomes they were pleased with, including a dismissal and a DWI resolved as a lesser ticket. Those are individual accounts. At 103 reviews, this is the deepest record on the list.
Why they fit Peekskill: The strongest fit of the three for the question of what the prosecution will offer and whether to take it, since the attorney handling criminal cases spent years on the other side and the review base is by far the deepest. The caveat is scale: this is a two-attorney firm whose other half practices real estate, so ask who covers a court date if Matthew Montana is on trial elsewhere. Note too that the firm’s site and Google list different addresses.
2. Law Office of Robert M. Nachamie
Best for DWI and traffic charges in Westchester and Dutchess courts
Robert Nachamie’s site puts criminal law, DWI, and traffic tickets first, and its town pages cover Peekskill, Westchester, and Dutchess courts. He has run his own office on Park Street since 2006, after earlier work at an insurance defense firm. For anyone looking for a Peekskill criminal and DWI lawyer who will meet at the office or somewhere more convenient, and who offers payment plans and takes credit cards, this solo practice is built around that kind of case.
Identity and footprint
Office1011 Park Street, Suite 5, Peekskill, NY 10566
Address noteLawyers.com lists 1015 Park Street, Suite 5
Phone(914) 930-7978 office, (914) 774-0156 cell; the site says phones are monitored around the clock
Office hoursMonday to Thursday 8 a.m. to 5 p.m., Friday 8 a.m. to 4 p.m.
MeetingsAt the Peekskill office or a location convenient to the client
Service areaWestchester and Dutchess counties, and New York City boroughs
Practice and scope
Core workCriminal law, DWI and traffic tickets
Charges listedDrug possession, assault, petty larceny, grand larceny, weapons, domestic violence, white-collar, juvenile matters
Other workPersonal injury, family law, contracts, landlord and tenant
Assigned casesA testimonial on his own site describes him as the client’s public defender
Credentials and licensing
New York bar admissionRobert M. Nachamie, registration 4061198, admitted 2002
Law schoolPace Law School, J.D.; B.A. in Sociology, Pace University
CareerEarlier work at the firm of Donald L. Frum, in-house counsel for an insurer; own office opened in 2006
BBBAccredited since November 2019; BBB lists the business as started in 2004
Fees and consultation
ConsultationDescribed as a no-obligation consultation
StructureThe site says time required is the main factor in the fee (firm site)
PaymentPayment plans available; credit cards accepted
What clients say
✓ Practical, low drama approach
✓ Ticket reported dismissed
✓ Clients refer friends
✗ One account of a long wait
· Only 12 Google reviews
Reviewers describe a practical lawyer who gets to the point, and several say they came by referral and later referred others. One describes a Peekskill ticket dismissed with no points. By contrast, one detailed review describes waiting well past a scheduled appointment after quick, early responses. That is one account, and twelve reviews is a small base.
Why they fit Peekskill: The most focused of the three on DWI and traffic matters, with town pages for Peekskill and Dutchess courts, and the only one that publishes payment plans and card payments. The caveat is that it’s a solo practice with a small review base, one complaint about a long wait for an appointment, and a site last updated in 2022 that still reads as if it were written around fifteen years ago. Ask who appears if he is in another court the same morning.
3. John M. Voelp Esq. PLLC
Best for a criminal charge tied to other legal problems, from a long-serving local generalist
John Voelp was born in Peekskill and has been admitted in New York since 1976, the longest record on this list. His site lists criminal law and DUI alongside real estate, elder law, estates, divorce, bankruptcy and immigration. That breadth suits cases where the charge is only part of the problem, such as an arrest that involves a lease, a family matter, or property. For a Peekskill attorney with five decades of local practice who can handle matters beyond the charge, this is the general practice option.
Identity and footprint
Office1013 Brown Street, Peekskill, NY 10566; mailing address PO Box 568
Address noteMartindale and Lawyers.com still list 8 John Walsh Blvd., Suite 411
Phone(914) 739-9500 and (914) 815-0284
EmailPublished as a Gmail address
Service areaHudson Valley towns from Ossining and Yorktown to Beacon, Fishkill, and Poughkeepsie
Practice and scope
Criminal workCriminal law and DUI pages for Peekskill and nearby towns
Other workCivil litigation, divorce, family, elder, estate, immigration, real estate, bankruptcy, landlord and tenant
Federal courtsAdmitted in the Southern and Eastern Districts of New York, 1976
TeamSite refers to a legal team and associates
Credentials and licensing
New York bar admissionJohn M. Voelp, registration 1092097, admitted 1976
EducationSyracuse University, B.A. 1973 and J.D. 1976
AssociationsPeekskill and New York State Bar Associations
Peer ratingMartindale peer review score of 4.0 from one review
Fees and consultation
ConsultationOffered through the site
AvailabilityThe site advertises a 24/7 support line
What clients say
✓ Careful, thorough advice
✓ Available when needed
✗ One account of a rude text
· Only 6 Google reviews
Reviewers describe a careful, available lawyer who gives seasoned advice, and one family credits him with thorough help on non-criminal matters. One reviewer says he sent a rude text message. With six reviews, most about criminal cases, the record says little about his courtroom work.
Why they fit Peekskill: The right call if your charge comes with a second problem, such as a property, family, or immigration question, and you want one lawyer with fifty years in Peekskill who can see both. The trade-off is focus: criminal defense is one of eleven areas on his site, no other attorney is named, and the reviews say little about criminal outcomes. If you are not a U.S. citizen, ask before any plea how it could affect your immigration status.
What to check before hiring a Criminal Defense Lawyer in Peekskill
✓ Look up the lawyer on the New York courts attorney search
The Unified Court System’s attorney search is free and shows registration number, year admitted, and registration status. Search the attorney who will stand next to you in court, not the firm name. None of the three firms publish a registration number on their sites.
✓ Ask for the fee in writing, and what happens at trial
Criminal defense is usually a flat fee per stage. Ask what the fee covers, whether a hearing or trial costs extra, and what happens if the case moves from City Court to County Court after an indictment.
✓ Do not skip your first court date
Missing an appearance can lead to a bench warrant. If you cannot afford a lawyer, say so at your first appearance, because New York assigns counsel to anyone who qualifies.
✓ If you are not a citizen, raise it at the first meeting
A seemingly minor plea can carry serious immigration consequences. Your lawyer must advise you on this, and the Legal Aid Society of Westchester runs a regional immigration assistance center that supports defense lawyers on this exact question.
✓ For a DWI, ask about your license separately
A DWI case has two tracks: the criminal charge and your driving privileges. Ask how the lawyer will handle any suspension, a refusal hearing, and whether a conditional license is possible while the case is pending.
Criminal Defense Lawyers in Peekskill: frequently asked questions
How much does a criminal defense lawyer cost in Peekskill?
None of the three practices on this page publishes its fees. Directories list free consultations and fixed fees for Levine & Montana, and Robert Nachamie publishes that he offers payment plans and takes credit cards. Ask for the fee for your specific charge in writing. Separately, a conviction carries a state surcharge and crime victim fee of $200 for a misdemeanor and $325 for a felony.
Which court will my case be in?
Peekskill City Court handles arrests within the City of Peekskill at 2 Nelson Avenue. City Court hears misdemeanors, violations and traffic matters and arraigns felonies. If a grand jury indicts a felony, the case moves to Westchester County Court in White Plains.
Can I get a free lawyer in Westchester County?
Yes, if you qualify. New York presumes you are eligible if your take-home income is at or below 250% of the federal poverty guidelines, and counsel should be assigned at your first appearance. The Legal Aid Society of Westchester represents people charged with felonies, and the county’s assigned counsel panel takes misdemeanors and violations. The Legal Aid Society’s number is 914-286-3400.
How long does a criminal case take in New York?
It depends on the charge, but New York’s speedy trial rule generally requires the prosecution to be ready within 90 days for a class A misdemeanor and six months for a felony, not counting delays the defense causes or consents to. Many cases resolve sooner through a plea or dismissal, and some take longer because of motions and adjournments.
What happens after a first DWI arrest in Peekskill?
You will have a criminal case in City Court and a separate license issue. A first misdemeanor DWI can carry a $500 to $1,000 fine, license revocation, and up to a year in jail, plus the mandatory surcharge. Many first offenses resolve as a lesser driving while ability impaired charge, but the facts and evidence determine the outcome.
DJA Editorial
Legal Directory Research
Compiles Distinguished Justice Advocates city guides from state bar and court registration records, court and statute sources, and publicly visible client reviews. Firms appear as a shortlist rather than a ranking. Figures a firm publishes about itself are labeled as such, and anything that could not be verified is flagged on the page rather than estimated.